Division and Destruction in King Lear Essay - 1662 Words

King Lear: Division of the Country, Destruction of the Family As Shakespeare’s King Lear opens, the political conditions in Britain are precarious. Lear is an aging king, four score and upward, with three daughters and no male heir. Sooner or later power must be transferred.nbsp; Through no mans fault, persons of extremely evil propensity were placed very close to power. This situation is an outer expression of the conditions of the social consciousness of the country. Until now Britain has been ruled by a powerful monarch who kept the country unified by his strength. There is no one of equal power to replace him. The solution which naturally suggests itself is a division into three parts, each to be ruled by a daughter and her†¦show more content†¦But as he is placed in life, Lears emotions are too much dominated by selfishness, vanity and egoism to express real love or affection. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp; As the country has come to a transition point, so has Lear. In his old age, he feels compelled to put aside the mantle of authority and spend his last days in the comfort and warmth of his youngest daughter Cordelias affection. There is in Lear an inner urge to renounce the satisfactions of power with which he is saturated and grow into the satisfactions of the heart. But there is also much in him which is so accustomed to the privileges and pleasures of absolute power that to give them up would itself seem like death. What takes place is a working out of the forces within his being, compelling and resisting a shift in consciousness from the vital to the emotional center. nbsp; Lear announces a contest in which the kingdom is to be divided among his three daughters and their husbands according to each ones profession of love and devotion to him. Even the manner in which he expresses his intention forebodes a different outcome. nbsp; Meantime we shall express our darker purpose. Give me the map there. Know that we have divided In three our kingdom; and tis our fast intent To shake all cares and business from our age, Conferring them on younger strengths, while we Unburdend crawl towardShow MoreRelatedEssay on Lears Character in William Shakespeares Play1216 Words   |  5 PagesLears Character in William Shakespeares Play The view of Lear being bent on his own destruction from the beginning of the play is an acceptable claim. The way he begins in the play, dividing up his country for his daughters, in essence, this spelt disaster. Unlike other renaissance dramatists, who used ‘mad scenes’ for comic use, Shakespeare seems intent onRead MoreWho Destructive Jealousy : The Side Effect Of Love937 Words   |  4 PagesSide-effects of Love in King Lear While love is a very common element in literature, it is not always presented in a good light or with a happy ending, but can rather be seen as underlying a certain darkness, as Shakespeare does so well in his tragedies. Insert transition about jealousy. In King Lear, the destructive side effects of love are shown in Lear’s relationship with his daughters and the love triangle between Goneril, Regan and Edmund. To begin, the love between King Lear and Cordelia breedsRead MoreRole Of A Fool Or Jester During Elizabethan Times1351 Words   |  6 Pagesespecially the King. The fool would sing, dance, make jokes and make a fool of himself. In Shakespeare’s King Lear, the fool has many roles. When Lear banishes Cordelia from his kingdom, the fool in a way takes on Cordelia s role. He is not only a fool, but through his sarcasm and irony, he becomes the king s loyal advocate by pointing out the king’s shortcomings. The fool is the only one who is able to criticize the king of his shortcomings without consequences and is able to abate the king s behaviorRead More Folly in William Shakespeares King Lear Essay2875 Words   |  12 PagesFolly in William Shakespeares King Lear      Ã‚  Ã‚   In East Coker, T. S. Eliot pleads Do not let me hear / Of the wisdom of old men, but rather of their folly†¦. (Eliot 185) The folly of old men must surely be a central trope in any discussion of Shakespeares imposing tragic accomplishment, King Lear. Traditional interpretations of the play, drawing on the classical Aristotelian theory of tragedy, have tended to view Lears act of blind folly as hamartia, precipitating the disintegration ofRead MoreAnalyzing the Characteristics of Kind Lear Essay4690 Words   |  19 PagesCharacteristics of Kind Lear Lear is the protagonist, whose willingness to believe his older daughters’ empty flattery leads to the deaths of many people. In relying on the test of his daughters’ love, Lear demonstrates that he lacks common sense or the ability to detect his older daughters’ falseness. Lear cannot recognize Cordelia’s honesty amid the flattery, which he craves. The depth of Lear’s anger toward Kent, his devoted follower, suggests excessive pride—Lear refuses to beRead MoreCritical Review of Macbeth by William Shakespeare1008 Words   |  5 PagesOverview In this, the play differs from Othello, where the hero commits murder only after long plotting, and from Hamlet (1600-1601), where the hero spends most of the play in moral indecision. It is more like King Lear (1605-1606), where destructive action flows from the central premise of the division of the kingdom. Yet Macbeth differs from that play, too, in that it does not raise the monumental, cosmic questions of good and evil in nature (Shakespeare, 1992). Instead it explores the moral and psychologicalRead MoreWilliam Shakespeare s Othello And The English Language1649 Words   |  7 PagesPoet, playwright, actor and dramatist, William Shakespeare is one of the most influential and greatest writers up to this day in poetry and the English language. Known, for his many acclaimed works such as his famous plays, â€Å"Othello,† â€Å"King Lear,† and â€Å"Romeo and Juliet† etc. More than four hundred years have passed and William Shakespeare’s work still aliv e as if it was during the early ages of Shakespeare work. Shakespeare influenced ranges from literature, theater, films and even the English languageRead MoreThe Tragic Hero and the Tragic Story in William Shakespeares Writing2842 Words   |  12 Pagesof whom the hero is one---OR, * Two Parties or Groups,one of which the hero leads---OR, * The passions, tendencies, ideas, principles, forces whichanimatethese persons or groups. In Richard II,for example, we have the King on one side and Henry Bollinbroke on the other. In Macbeth,we have the hero, Macbeth, and the heroine, Lady Macbeth, opposed to the representatives of Duncan, Malcolm, and Macduff. In all these cases, the great majority of the DramatisRead MoreWilliam Shakespeare s Romeo And Juliet2829 Words   |  12 Pagesrhymes with Benvolio’s last line, showing the continuity of the last act. Mercutio, who never felt the wound of love, may well jest at the scars which Cupid s arrows have left in my heart. As neither the folios nor the quartos make any division of scene, such division, originally due to Rowe, seems wrong. Since Shakespeare’s plays are poetic dramas, he often shifts from average word arrangements to the strikingly unusual so that the line will conform to the desired poetic rhythm. Today, English sentenceRead MoreThe Sonnet Form: William Shakespeare6305 Words   |  26 Pagesrandom from the truth vainly expressed;   Ã‚  Ã‚  For I have sworn thee fair and thought thee bright,   Ã‚  Ã‚  Who art as black as hell, as dark as night. In many ways, Shakespeare’s use of the sonnet form is richer and more complex than this relatively simple division into parts might imply. Not only is his sequence largely occupied with subverting the traditional themes of love sonnets—the traditional love poems in praise of beauty and worth, for instance, are written to a man, while the love poems to a woman

Disparity and Discrimination Free Essays

Criminal Justice System has long been established in order to guide all law enforcers and legal officers in the implementation of laws and order in achieving justice. The law provides for strict prohibition of any signs of unfairness. However, the system is faced with issues of disparity and discrimination that continues to cast doubt as to the implementation of the law. We will write a custom essay sample on Disparity and Discrimination or any similar topic only for you Order Now Disparity refers to the â€Å"idea that individuals who commit the same or similar offenses receive different punishment† (Justice Works, 2008). Discrimination, on the other hand, refers to the â€Å"act of singling out a certain individual or group fro unfair treatment based on race, class, gender, or status† (Calderon). In criminal justice system, both disparity and discrimination are illegal. While disparity may not be intentional it is always unacceptable in the system. Discrimination, on the other hand, is always done intentionally. In addition, disparity is concern with the differences in outcome while discrimination deals with equal treatment (Gelsthorpe and Padfield, 2003, p. 4). In criminal justice, disparity has been apparent in the juvenile proceedings. According to research, more juvenile minorities have been detained in public secure facilities while whites were housed in private secure facilities (Snyder and Sickmund, 1995). In addition, discrimination is also prevalent because of different treatment afforded to blacks and whites. Disparity usually occurs when more blacks were detained than whites who had committed same crime. Discrimination, on the other hand, occurs when detention of black was based on his race. In avoiding disparity, it is necessary that the legal factors such as seriousness of the crime and criminal history should be considered in the decision making (Calderon). Discrimination may also be avoided by implementing the law equally. References Calderon, M. (04 September 2006). AnairHoads. Org. Disparity and Discrimination. Retrieved January 28, 2009, from http://www.anairhoads.org/calderon/disdisc.shtml Gelsthorpe, L. and Padfield, N. (2003). Exercising Discretion: Decision Making in the Criminal Justice System and Beyond. Willan Publishing. Justice Works. (2008). Analysis of Racism in the Criminal Justice System. Retrieved January 28, 2009, from http://www.justiceworks.info/index.php?module=pagemasterPAGE_user_op=view_pagePAGE_id=41MMN_position=54:4 Snyder, H. N., and Sickmund, M. (1995). Juvenile Offenders and Victims: A National Report. Washington, D.C.: DIANE Publishing. How to cite Disparity and Discrimination, Papers

The major themes in Our Day Out Essay Example

The major themes in Our Day Out Essay Our Day Out is set in inner city Liverpool in the mid 1970s. The fictional school is located in a neighbour with a high crime rate, drug use, prostitution, high unemployment, poverty and domestic abuse. The kids in the schools remedial class are all portrayed as economically unstable, poor and deprived children with different stories which reinforce the key ideas of the play. In 1981 there was rioting in Toxteth, a deprived district of Liverpool of which high unemployment rates were blamed for. The setting of the play acts as a prelude to the riots. Willy Russell adds elements of subtle humour which make the play funny and sad at the same time Early on in the play we are introduced to Carol Chandler who is evidently one of the poorest children in the class when she is revealed to be wearing a school uniform which doubles as a street outfit and a Sunday best, eating half a sandwich and clutching a carrier bag Here Russell is introducing us to one of the focal characters with a description which suggests that Carols family cant afford to buy here a school bag, have to share food and cant afford many clothes. We will write a custom essay sample on The major themes in Our Day Out specifically for you for only $16.38 $13.9/page Order now We will write a custom essay sample on The major themes in Our Day Out specifically for you FOR ONLY $16.38 $13.9/page Hire Writer We will write a custom essay sample on The major themes in Our Day Out specifically for you FOR ONLY $16.38 $13.9/page Hire Writer This portrayal of Carol is important as it shows the signs of social deprivation and establishes her economic status. She describes Conwy as somewhere far away, I forget (in response to Les the lollipop mans question as to where the trips destination is). This also tells us she hasnt been far from home before since if shed been to Conwy before shed would know it is only about an hour away from Liverpool. We feel a little sorry for Carol and feel guilty about her having to live like that while our homes are often full of materialistic goods and appliances that we take for granted. When up on the cliff she refuses to return to the trip and wants to stay in Wales. We immediately get a sense of her naivety though it is a quality rather than a weakness and she clearly doesnt mean any harm at all. Carol has another quality of being appreciative of lifes simple things i. e. nature,since she cant posses materialistic products for a small price, this is a quality we all hope to have . She reveals to Mrs Kay-whom she looks to for mentoring, friendship and sometimes motherly love, which she cant get at home that she wants to live in one of them nice places with trees and that and underneath Mrs Kays encouraging facade, she knows Carol is stuck in the poverty cycle and wants to get out. Them nice places also shows Carols lack of education. This is tragic but Carols implicit disorganisation and forgetfulness accounts for the plays humour-I find this technique a very clever and powerful way of entertaining the audience and conveying the reality of these deprived childrens lifestyles. The play also focuses on Andrews, one of Carols peers in the progress class who has a similar lifestyle. Firstly, we learn that he smokes. He tells Reilly (an older ex-progress class student) to Gis a ciggy, in return for opening the window. Willy Russell continues with the theme of social deprivation by exposing Andrews mother as a prostitute when Digga refers to all them fellas she picks up This also tells us that Andrews mother not only has to practise promiscuity but has to risk her life on the streets of inner city Liverpool and we start to worry about Andrews mother putting her life at risk which makes us feel sorry. The aforementioned quote also shows bad education and not being able to speak properly. When Briggs tells Andrews off for smoking, he is told that Andrews mother doesnt take any notice but me dad, he belts me Ironically, Andrews is beaten because he wont give his father a cigarette. Andrews has a nasty life and we take pity and feel empathic but the aforementioned irony accounts for the plays humour, as does Briggs lack of understanding when he assumes Andrews father returns home because he is in the forces, when really, all he wants is the money. This portrayal of Andrews establishes the area of where the school is situated a deprived area and includes individual cases of families struggling to survive. Russell also uses Reilly, an ex-progress class student as a mouthpiece for his ideas and to convey aspects of social deprivation. We learn that Reillys dad works at the docks and hates it. Unrealistically, Briggs tells Reilly to tell his father to stop and take a look around. He may see things different then, an unrealistic expectation. Here we get a view of the docks through two different perspectives. To Briggs, an affluent middle class teacher the docks are historic and something to be proud of. To Reilly and his dad however, they are their means of employment which they have spent their lives trying to get away from. We also learn that Reilly has been motherless for ten years when Digga tells Briggs he cant swear on his mum sir shes been dead for ten years Reilly is in love with Susan, a young teacher in her early twenties who wouldnt go out with Reilly in a million years. Whether Reilly is being serious isnt revealed, but it is possible that Reilly is fishing for Susans money, in other words a goldigger. This possibility shows that Reilly doesnt have enough money of his own, so Russell is making us aware of social deprivation, a theme of the play. Reilly clearly has no respect for people above him in the school hierarchy, which shows lack of education, one of the plays theme. Later on in the play Susan turns the tables on Reilly and makes sudden advances and Russell manipulates the audience into believing she is being serious. She later tells him to stick to his own league and so forms a bond with 15-year-old Linda Croxley, a far more appropriate girlfriend for Reilly. We feel sorry for Reilly but being a motherless child has toughened him up and taught him to survive but his crush on Susan has a lot of comic element so contributes to the plays humour. Mr Briggs and Mrs Kay are focused upon heavily during the play who both have very different views on which teaching method is better for the remedial class. In a conversation with Colin, a young, less experienced teacher Briggs says well you have to risk being disliked if youre to do any good for these children and refers to Mrs Kays teaching method as woolly-headed liberalism. From this we can easily draw a conclusion that Mr Briggs doesnt think about the consequences of ruthlessness and all he is concerned about is positive results. Briggs obviously thinks because the kids missed out on a lot of education earlier in life they need some sort of intensive education technique if things are to be put right. He clearly sees respect from the kids as a nice extra when really it is essential. Also, when Mrs Kay changes the itinerary of the trip and takes the class to the zoo, Mr Briggs response tells us he doesnt want to deviate from the schedule and keep the kids bored, something in Briggs opinion would do the kids a bit of good. Colin later calls Mr Briggs a burke, and from this we can deduce that Mr Briggs is no more popular with his colleagues as he is with the students. On the other hand, Mrs Kay has a far more relaxed approach to educating the kids and a motherly, matriarchal attitude to the children-the two qualities awarding her street-cred with the kids. Mr Briggs sees this as a bad thing (he also thinks she has a motherly air) and he thinks if the antics in her department are anything to go by she always reminded me of a mother hen rather than a teacher. From this quote we can conclude that Mrs Kay is less popular with her colleagues, though the opinions of the other staff on her philosophical view of education are undisclosed. During a chat with Carol on the coach, Mrs Kay puts her arm around Carol and the stage directions at this point describe this as looking like a mother and daughter. Later on in the play she reveals explicitly that she is on the childrens side though this doesnt come as a surprise to the audience. This relationship is important since Carol has to look to her teacher for mentoring and motherly love which she cant get at home. This creates a possibility that Carols family maybe bad parents, socially deprived and not respectable. This reinforces the theme of social deprivation. All of these points establish Mr Briggs and Mrs Kays personalities and define the opposing forces. Willy Russell uses this opposition to manipulate the audience into wondering what will happen to the children with two completely different teachers taking control of them for the day, providing some of the plays humour. It also reveals societys opposing viewpoints about education. Throughout the play, stage directions are used to conjure up more explicit visions of what is going on. They are very important because if you are reading the play the more visual humour is hard to convey with words alone. At the start of the play, in the morning the kids are streaming in one direction. They [the kids] are shoving, rushing, ambling, leering and jeering. Here the strong use of verbs adds to the clarity of the description and leering and jeering suggests that there could be bullying going on. This shows lack of education- the kids obviously dont know what is right and wrong and have a poor sense of ethics (also evident in stealing the animals and taking them on to the coach). Stage directions can also express the humour that cant be conveyed with words alone. Just before leaving the zoo the animal keeper runs up to the coach polo-necked and wellied. Russell could have easily omitted that description but running in wellies is almost impossible. The image of someone running in something hard to run in e. g. stilettos, wellies, ski boots etc. is often used as a scene of slapstick humour- as opposed to the more dry, subtle humour used earlier on in the play. Also, animals appear from every conceivable hiding place and the coach is a menagerie. This stage direction pictures animals swarming around a small area(the coach), scuttling from side to side, jumping out of luggage lockers and generally causing chaos. This scene accounts for the plays humour but in my opinion, it is hard to fully appreciate without a graphical representation. The visual medium of TV allows Willy Russell to use the device of visual metaphor. While the class are in the zoo they are compared to a captive bear in an implicit way and are trapped in different ways. The bear is literally trapped in the pit for visitors and tourists to see and it cant do much, if anything to get out. The children, on the other hand are trapped in a more metaphorical way and stuck at their level in the social hierarchy and in the poverty cycle. From Briggs line dont forget it was born in captivity so it wont know any other life, we get the impression Briggs feels the children should stay working class rather than climb the pecking order to a middle or upper class rank and mixing with the more affluent Liverpudlians, while keeping their coarse and vulgar demeanours. From this we can tell Briggs is politically right-wing and if real, would have been one of the many Britons who decided it was time for James Callaghan to call it a day it 1979. Mrs Kay thinks the children deserve better but is unsure as to which route in life is best for the kids. Russell uses this technique again at the castle when comparing Mr Briggs old-fashioned teaching methods to the archaic, medieval castle-despite the fact he is younger than Mrs Kay, though you wouldnt think so. At the castle there is also a showdown between Mrs Kay and Mr Briggs, and the castle provides the perfect backdrop for it. Mrs Kays idea of visiting the modern zoo goes well with her modern philosophical view of education. However, Mrs Kays expectations of the kids are a bit too low and arent likely to bring out the full potentials of the kids. Conversely, Briggs are too high and are less realistic than Mrs Kays. Although neither teachers expectations are perfect (expectations of a teacher who gives the kids push and support simultaneously would be), Mrs Kays are more appropriate on the whole, and despite being too soft on the kids, Mrs Kay seems to know it is better to under-expect rather than to over-expect like Mr Briggs does because his views of education are far from appropriate and are no better for the kids than Mrs Kays. Willy Russell moves the play to a more dramatic climax which creates suspense-a literary device previously unused in the play. Carols naivety is reinforced by her explicit desire to remain in Wales. At this point Briggs doesnt change in personality but is now powerless and has no way of controlling Carols erratic and suicidal behaviour though knowing Briggs he is probably more concerned about being struck off and a legal inquiry than Carols state of mind and only told her she had hope to avoid the two aforementioned crises. When Briggs changes his ways Russell manipulates the audience into thinking Briggs is changing permanently and he will help the kids catch up and excel in life. However our expectations are dashed when the class returns to the city. When Reilly describes the city as horrible when you come back to it, Russell tells the audience that the children must be used to their neighbourhood after 13-15 years of entrapment in the inner city. Linda is unsure what Reilly is talking about which shows that she was taken in by the trip. Russells message to the audience is that living in the inner city of Liverpool can toughen one up and as a result, enables the kids to survive almost anything. The ending is disappointing yet realistic and Briggs making a fool of himself through singing a ridiculous song in a cowboy hat adds a humorous side to this sombre scene.

Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis essays

Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis essays Imagine sharp pains shooting through your legs and arms, problems in all of your muscles and knowing that you are going to die soon, at a considerably young age. These symptoms are only a few of the many signs that a person might be suffering from Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis. These are the same symptoms that my Uncle went through when he suffered from ALS. He died two and a half years after he was diagnosed, at the age of forty-six, which goes to show that it doesn't take long for the disease to progress, and there is obviously no cure. Also known as ALS or Lou Gehrig's disease, this fatal condition regularly kills innocent people. Some think that ALS is a rare disease and that it will never affect them, but they think wrong. More people need to be aware of ALS, especially the statistics, effects and treatment/prognosis of this morbid disease. The facts and statistics of Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS) show that the disease is rare, yet bitter. To begin with, the term ALS was coined for a specific reason. "Amyotrophic" means poor muscle nourishment. "Lateral" refers to the edges of the spinal cord. "Sclerosis" means hardening and scarring. Therefore, Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis is a disease that attacks the muscles and spinal cord, which slowly and painfully kills its victim. The cause of ALS is unknown, however, in a study done by Harvard University School of Public Health, scientists concluded that male war veterans from World War I through Vietnam are sixty percent more likely to develop ALS than non-veterans (Ruben 1). There are many theories as to what causes ALS, but this study is the only one that shows what might cause the disease. ALS affects people both sexes between 40 and 70 years old (What is ALS/MND? 1). ALS is more common in men than woman, a ratio of two to one (1). To add to that, one must consider life span and rarity statistics. In the ...

How to Study for an Open Book Test

How to Study for an Open Book Test Open book tests teach you how to find information when you need it, and under a significant amount of pressure.   Even more importantly, the questions are designed to teach you how to use your brain. And contrary to popular belief, you do not get off the hook when it comes to studying for an open book exam. You just need to study a little differently. Open Book Test Questions Most often, the questions on an open book test will ask you to explain, evaluate, or compare information from your textbook. For instance: Compare and contrast the different views of Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton as they pertained to the role and size of the government. When you see a question of this nature, dont bother scanning your book to find a statement that summarizes the topic for you. Most likely, the answer to this question will not appear in a single paragraph in your text- or even on a single page. The question requires you to have an understanding of two philosophical views that you could only comprehend by reading the entire chapter. During your exam, you will not have time to find enough information to answer this question well. Instead, you should know the basic answer to the question and, during the test, look for information from your book that will support your answer. How to Prepare for an Open Book Test If you have an upcoming open book test, take the following steps to prepare. Read the chapters ahead of time. Dont expect to find quick answers during the test.Know where to find everything. Observe headings and sub-headings and make your own outline. This reinforces the structure of the text in your mind.Mark all important terms with sticky notes and flags. If the teacher allows it, mark your texts with these removable tags wherever you notice important concepts and terms. Be sure to ask first!Review lecture notes for themes. Your teachers lectures usually provide an overview of the themes and concepts that appear on tests. You wont always get this by reviewing the book alone.Make your own notes if allowed, and write down important formulas or concepts that you’ve covered in class. What to Do During the Open Book Test First, evaluate each question. Ask yourself if each question requires facts or interpretation. The questions that require facts may be easier and faster to answer. Fact-based questions will begin with expressions like: List five reasons . . . What events led up to. . .? Some students like to answer the fact-based questions first, then move on to the interpretation questions, which require more thought and concentration. As you answer each question, you will need to quote the book when appropriate to back up your thoughts. Be sure to quote only three to five words at a time- otherwise, you may find yourself copying answers from the book, which will result in a loss of points.

Utilitarian versus Retributivist Views Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words

Utilitarian versus Retributivist Views - Essay Example The essence, focal points, main ideas and the merits of these two main theories are therefore to be discussed forthwith, in the ensuing discourse. Primarily, utilitarianism places focus on the consequences of the punishment, while retributivism is concerned with the retributive justice which is associated with the infliction of harm on the transgressor. Ideas Used In Utilitarian or Retributivist Theories Given that that utilitarianism is both a theory of punishment and ethics, it mainly takes on a consequentialist nature, because of its particular focus on the consequences of actions that have been executed by a particular group or an individual. Because of this, the moral theoretical standpoint of utilitarianism is that the balance of good and bad in a given action generates either good or bad. Under the principle of the greatest good for the greatest number, pain stems from the bad, while pleasure, from the good. Because of this, pain and pleasure are taken by utilitarians as the y ardsticks for values in a utilitarian system. The import of this is that utilitarians deem punishment as being evil in itself, or intrinsically evil. The evil that utilitarians see in the infliction of punishment is premised on the assumption that punishment heralds suffering or unhappiness. Utilitarians hold it that despite the negative connotations of punishment, yet its consequences can be positive, and hence, justifiable (Ewing, 1927). On the converse, retributionists see punishment as being intrinsically good. In fact, so convinced are retributionists about the goodness of punishment that that they assert that even if it appears that nothing beneficial will come from the meting out of punishment, yet it is expedient. This is to the extent that Emmanuel Kant waxes polemical that even if the end of the world should be imminent, yet the need to execute the last murder convict in prison is still indispensible. To retributivism, the meting out of punishment is intrinsically good sin ce: it is needful for the dispensation of justice; it allows people the chance to be treated in the manner that they deserve; and it allows people to treat one another with utmost respect, as autonomous agents, given that their choices and actions determine how they will be treated, in turn. In this case, there is justification of punishment since it is premised on a rational individual’s action. To utilitarians, the retributional approach to punishment and justification is unfavorable since it only increases the extent of suffering in the world, instead of abating it. Again, utilitarians posit that by vouching for the meting out of punishment, instead of reducing the suffering of this world, retributionists compound them, without making any reimbursements for them. Because of this, the retributionist approach does not move the world towards utmost happiness (the greatest pleasure for the greatest number), but away from it. The gravity of this is that utilitarianism takes awa y from the justification of punishment, given that punishment imposes suffering (Leo, 2006). Instead, for the utilitarians, the justification

Vicarious Liability for Police Supervisors Research Paper

Vicarious Liability for Police Supervisors - Research Paper Example The law has with considerable forethought, extended the scope of this doctrine to encompass the activities of the police. Thus, senior police officials are under a duty to supervise the activities of their subordinate officers. They are directly liable to the public for the acts of their subordinates (Del Carmen 107). This rule applies even when they authorize, participate, or ratify such acts. These senior officials are also liable, when the act had been committed in their presence and it had been possible for them to prevent it, but they had preferred to remain indifferent. Vicarious liability connotes indirect responsibility for the negligent actions of subordinates. Such conduct could be the outcome of negligence in hiring, training, assignment, supervision, entrustment, or retention (Del Carmen 107). The State laws may render police supervisors liable for the actions affecting subordinates. In general, direct liability tends to be related to the reasons for which employees could be reassigned, suspended, demoted, or dismissed from service. The provisions of Title 42 Section 1983 are generally invoked, in order to render a police supervisor directly liable to the public (Del Carmen 107). ... In addition, these police supervisors have to enhance their awareness regarding the actions and competencies of their subordinates. As such, police supervisors should recommence the fundamental tasks of continually supervising, teaching, updating, and controlling their subordinates. This will prevent to a major extent, the various civil rights actions that tend to be undertaken on a regular basis against the actions of the police. In the contemporary world, there has been a tremendous increase and development in technologies related to computers, the Internet and communications (Grossman). Consequently, the cost of providing refresher courses and documentation on a continual basis should not exceed the cost of a legal action for failure of the municipality to provide proper training and adequate supervision, with regard to its law enforcement officers (Grossman). In Suders v Easton, the plaintiff was a police communications operator, who resigned from her post without officially info rming the police department of her having been subjected to sexual harassment. Subsequently, she sued the police department for sexual harassment in violation of Title VII. Her contention was that her resignation was tantamount to a constructive discharge (Bass 195). The Third Circuit ruled that a constructive discharge on account of sexual harassment by a supervisor was a tangible employment action. This ruling effectively precluded the police department’s affirmative defense to vicarious liability. Such an affirmative defense can be resorted to when the sexual harassment does not lead to a tangible employment action (Bass 195). However, this important ruling was overturned by the Supreme Court in Pennsylvania State Police v Suders. The reason